Bill Pay

We offer several different options for you to pay your bill to make it as easy for you as possible. You can pay online using the links below, or you can contact us by phone or by stopping into our office.


American Collectors Insurance Logo

American Collectors Insurance

Billing Phone:

1-800-360-2277

Flood Billing:

1-800-356-6670

Billing Address:

American Collectors
PO Box 8343
Cherry Hill, NJ 08002

Overnight Mail:

American Collectors
496 Kings Highway North
Cherry Hill, NJ 08034
Details:

You will need your policy number and can use a Visa, Discover, American Express, or MasterCard to pay.

Once you create an account you can:

  • Pay your bill
  • View your policy information
  • Print ID card(s)
  • Report a claim
  • Update account information
  • Renew your policy
  • Request policy changes
American Modern Insurance Logo

American Modern Insurance Group

Billing Phone

1-800-543-2644

Billing Address:

American Modern Insurance Group
PO Box 5323
Cincinnati, OH 45201-5323

Overnight Mail:

American Modern Insurance Group
Attn: account payment processing
7000 Midland Blvd.
Amelia, OH 45102-2607
Details:

You will need your policy number.

If you create an account you can:

  • Pay your bill
  • View your policy information
  • Report and view claims
  • Update account information

Save time every month by having your payment withdrawn automatically. Sign up for EZPay.

Dryden Mutual Insurance Company Logo

Dryden Mutual Insurance Company

Billing Phone:

1-800-694-8271
available Monday-Friday,
8:30am-4:30pm

Billing Address:

Dryden Mutual Insurance Company
PO Box 635
Dryden, NY 13053-0635

More Info »
Details:

Pay your bill online and view policy documents and invoices. You’ll need your invoice to setup your account.

For a cancellation for non-payment, you can use a Visa or MasterCard to pay Dryden Mutual by phone. You can also use a Visa or MasterCard to pay the down payment on a new policy in our office.

To enroll in EFT call 800-694-8271 during business hours (8:30 a.m.-4:30 p.m., M-F) and make a payment using any major credit card or an ACH transfer from a checking or savings account.

Finger Lakes Fire & Casualty Company Logo

Finger Lakes Fire & Casualty Company

Billing Phone:

1-607-387-6800

Billing Address:

6905 Route 227
PO Box 550
Trumansburg, NY 14886
Details:

You will need your policy number and can use a Debit, Visa, Discover, or MasterCard to pay.

Foremost Insurance Group Logo

Foremost Insurance Group

Billing Phone:

1-800-532-4221
available Monday-Friday,
9am-8pm

Automated Phone System:

1-800-532-4221
available Monday-Friday,
7am-12midnight
Saturday, 7am-5pm

Billing Address:

Foremost Insurance Group
PO Box 0915
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0915
Details:

You do not need to have an account in order to pay your bill. Without a login, you will need the policy holder’s name, date of birth, zip code, and policy number.

To pay, you can use your Checking/Savings Account or a Visa or MasterCard.

You can now enroll and manage your Auto Pay Direct Debit online:

  • Login to your account
  • Navigate to “Billing”
  • Select “Auto Pay Direct Debit”
Haterty Logo

Hagerty Insurance

Billing Phone:

1-800-922-4050

Billing Address:

Hagerty Insurance Agency
PO Box 1303
Traverse City, MI 49685-1303
Details:

You will need the policy holder’s date of birth and policy number. To pay, you can use your Checking Account or an American Express, Visa, Discover, or MasterCard.

Once you are signed up, you can:

  • Receive emails
  • View and print your policy documents (ID cards and declaration pages)
  • Have 24/7 access to your account information
  • Pay your bill
  • Make changes to your policy.

Customer Service representatives are available to chat online Monday-Friday, 8:30am-8pm.

Kemper Insurance Logo

Kemper Preferred Insurance

Billing Phone:

Automated Service
1-877-488-7488
available 24/7

Billing Address:

Kemper Preferred
PO Box 70839
Charlotte, NC 28272-0839
Details:

You will need your policy number and can use your Checking/Savings Account or a Visa or MasterCard to pay.

Once you create a Customer Login, you can:

  • Pay your bill
  • Sign up for automatic payments
  • Go Paperless
  • Get ID cards for your auto policy
  • Track a filed claim
  • View your agent’s contact information

Save time each month by enrolling in automatic EFT or credit card payments. Download the enrollment forms:

Or contact us for more information.

Mercury Insurance Logo

Mercury Insurance Group

Billing Phone:

1-800-503-3724
Available every day, 8am-1am

Billing Address:

Mercury Insurance Group
PO Box 11991
Santa Ana, CA 92711
Details:

You will need the policy holder’s date of birth, zip code, and policy number. To pay, you can use an American Express, Visa, NYCE, Star, Pulse, or MasterCard.

Never forget to pay your bill by enrolling in automatic EFT payments. Download the form or contact us for more information.

National General Insurance Logo

National General Insurance

Billing Phone:

1-800-462-2123
Details:

You will need your policy number to log into your account. You can also make a one-time quick payment without creating an account.

You can now pay your bill, update contact information, view your policy, request ID cards, and file claims online.

Nationwide Insurance Logo

Nationwide Insurance

Billing Phone:

1-866-665-4992
Available 24/7

Billing Address:

Nationwide Insurance
Payment Processing Center
PO Box 37712
Philadelphia, PA 19101-5012
Details:

You will need your policy number and zip code. To pay, you can use a one-time EFT, a recurring EFT from your Checking/Savings or Money Market Account, or a Visa, Discover, or MasterCard.

Formerly known as Harleysville Insurance.

New York Central Mutual Insurance Logo

New York Central Mutual Insurance

Billing Phone:

1-800-234-6926
available 24/7

Billing Address:

New York Central Mutual
1899 Central Plaza East
Edmeston, NY 13335-1899
Details:

Details: You will need the policyholder’s last name, zip code, and policy number. To pay, you can use a Visa, Discover, or MasterCard.

You can also register for My Account to manage your policy.  In “My Account” you can:

  • Make or schedule a payment
  • Change your billing plan
  • View your declaration page and ID Cards
  • Submit or view a claim
  • Review your policy coverages

Never forget to pay your bill by enrolling in automatic EFT payments. Download the form or contact us for more information.

More Info

New York State Insurance Fund Logo

New York State Insurance Fund

Billing Phone:

1-877-309-6028

Billing Address:

New York State Insurance Fund Workers' Compensation
PO Box 5262
Binghamton, NY 13902-5262
Details:

You will need the policy holder’s bill number, payment amount, and policy number. To pay, you can use a one-time EFT or an American Express, Discover, or MasterCard.

A 2.5% convenience fee is added to each credit card transaction by “Official Payments Corporation.”

You can also elect to pay via NYSIF Paygo, which allows you to pay your workers’ comp through approved payroll processors.

Peerless Insurance Logo

Peerless Insurance

Billing Phone:

1-800-228-7830
Available Monday-Friday,
8am-8pm

Billing Address:

Peerless Insurance
PO Box 703
Keene, NH 03431
Details:

You will need your policy number and can use your Checking Account, a Visa or MasterCard Debit Card, or a Visa or MasterCard Credit Card to pay. Credit Card payments are only available if you are paying your balance in full.

You must register for OSBC (Online Billing Service Center) in order to pay bills online. Once you have created your account, you can:

  • Pay your bill
  • Enroll in EFT Automatic Withdrawals
  • Have 24/7 access to your account status and payment history
Philadelphia Insurance Companies Logo

Philadelphia Insurance Companies

Billing Phone:

1-877-438-7459

Billing Address:

Philadelphia Insurance Companies
PO Box 70251
Philadelphia, PA 19176-0251
Details:

You will need the policy holder’s full name, account number, and policy number. To pay, you can use a one-time EFT. Hours are M-F: 8:30am – 8:00pm.

Progressive Insurance Comercial Lines

Progressive Commercial Insurance

Billing Phone:

1-800-876-5581

Billing Address:

use payment stub,
but if sending without a stub mail to:
Progressive Insurance
DEPT 0561
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0561
Details:

Scroll down for Personal Insurance information

You will need the policy holder’s zip code and policy number, and the birthdate of any driver on the policy. To pay, you can use a Credit Card or recurring EFT.

Progressive Insurance Personal Lines

Progressive Personal Insurance

Billing Phone:

1-800-876-5581
or 1-800-PROGRESSIVE
available 24/7

Billing Address:

use payment stub,
but if sending without a stub mail to:
Progressive Insurance
DEPT 0561
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0561
Details:

You will need the policy holder’s zip code, the policy number, and the birthdate of any driver on the policy. To pay, you can use your Checking Account or a Visa, Discover, NYCE, Star, Pulse, or MasterCard.

For general inquiry emails, click on the contact link at the top right of the page, then click on the email link. There is an option to have the website converted to Spanish if desired.

If you create an online account, you can:

  • Make changes to your policy such as

-Updating your address
-Changing vehicle information
-Adding new drivers

  • Get a quote to see how a change may affect your premium
  • Go paperless
  • Have 24/7 access to your account information

To pay via mobile app you’ll need to download it from the Apple App Store or Google Play store and then login using your Progressive online credentials.

Or text PGR to 69979 to download the app.

Or save time each month and never forget about your bill by enrolling in recurring automated payments. Download the form or contact us for more information.

SafeCo Insurance Company Logo

Safeco Insurance

Billing Phone:

1-888-723-3260

Billing Address:

Attn: Pymt Processing Ops
Safeco Ins Companies
PO Box 10002
Manchester, NH 03108-1002
Details:

You will need the policy number and the policy holder’s address.  You can use your Checking Account or an American Express, Visa, Discover, or MasterCard to pay.

To make a payment online you must register to manage your account. Once registered, you can:

  • Pay your bill
  • Track your claims
  • View your policy documents
  • Print new insurance ID cards
  • and more

Learn about Safeco’s billing plans or sign up for easy, recurring automated payments with this formContact us for more information.

 

ShelterPoint Life Insurance Company Logo

ShelterPoint Life Insurance Company

Billing Phone:

1-800-365-4999

Billing Address:

ShelterPoint Life
1225 Franklin Ave, Ste 475
PO Box 9340
Garden City, NY 11530
payment must accompany the Premium Report "Audit" form.
Details:

To register for access to log into your policy and claim information, you will need your policy number and your zip code.

Payments can be mailed in with the self-audit form sent to you by ShelterPoint Life, or you may complete the form and make payments online.

There is an instructional video on how to use E-pay if you have any questions.

The Hartford Commercial Insurance

The Hartford Commercial Insurance

Billing Phone:

1-866-467-8730
available Monday-Friday, 8am-8pm

Billing Address:

The Hartford
PO Box 660916
Dallas, TX 75266-0916
Details:

You can register to make online payments. You will need your policy number or account number and your billing zip code. If you are in pending cancellation status, Hartford recommends that you call instead of setting up a new account.

Credit card payment is now available to pay in full or to pay off a remaining balance – log in to your account.

Save time each month by enrolling in automatic EFT payments. Download the form or contact us for more information.

The Hartford Personal Insurance

The Hartford Personal Insurance

Billing Phone (Homeowners):

1-800-624-5578
available Monday-Friday, 8am-8pm

Billing Phone (Auto):

1-877-896-9320
available Monday-Friday, 7am-11pm
Saturday, 8am-5pm

Billing Address:

The Hartford
PO Box 660916
Dallas, TX 75266-0916
Details:

Scroll down for Commercial Insurance information

You will need your policy number or account number and your billing zip code. To pay online, you can use an American Express, Visa, Discover, or MasterCard. By phone, you can take the payment from your Checking Account.

Once you are signed up to manage your account, you can:

  • Pay your bill
  • Report or track a claim
  • View your policy
  • View/Print Documents

Save time each month by enrolling in automatic EFT paymentsContact us for more information.

The Main Street America Group Logo

The Main Street America Group

Billing Phone:

Automated Service
1-800-611-0958

Customer Service
1-888-333-4014

Billing Address:

The Main Street America Group
PO Box 2004
Keene, NH 03431
Details:

You will need the policy holder’s zip code and policy number. To pay, you can use your Checking Account, recurring EFT, or a Visa, Discover, or MasterCard.

Bill payment is available online and by phone, billing inquiry is not available.

en Español (in Spanish)

You can pay future installments in advance.

Save time each month and never forget to pay your bill by enrolling in automatic EFT payments. Download the form or contact us for more information.

Travelers Insurance Commercial Lines

Travelers Commercial Insurance

Billing Phone:

1-800-252-2268
available Monday-Friday,
7am-8pm

Billing Address:

Travelers Commercial Lines
PO Box 660317
Dallas, TX 75266-0317
Details:

Scroll down for Personal Insurance information

For a one-time EFT payment, Express Pay is available.  You will need the policy number or account number and the billing address zip code.  To sign up for an online account that will store your payment information, have your most recent bill available. Registration may take a few days to be confirmed, so you won’t want to wait until the bill due date to sign up.

To pay, you can use Check-by-Phone, single EFT, or automatic recurring payments from a Checking/Savings Account. Register for recurring Travelers ePay payments.

You can also sign up online for paperless billing.

Travelers Insurance Personal Lines

Travelers Personal Insurance

Billing Phone:

1-800-842-5075
available Monday-Friday, 8:45am-11pm
Saturday 8:45-5pm

Billing Address:

Travelers Personal Insurance
PO Box 660307
Dallas, TX 75266-0307
Details:

Have your most recent bill available to sign up for online access. Registration may take a few days to be confirmed, so you won’t want to wait until the bill due date to sign up. To pay, you can use your Checking/Savings Account or a Visa or MasterCard.

You can also enroll in EFT from your Checking/Savings Account and set up recurring credit card payments online.

There is an option to have the website converted to Spanish if desired.

Learn why you should create your MyTravelers account.

Save time and postage each month by signing up for automated recurring EFT payments. Download the form or contact us for more information.

Get billing related questions answered by Alexa! Search for Travelers in Alexa Skills using your Amazon app. Learn more at Amazon.com/skills.

Utica National Insurance Logo

Utica National Insurance Group

Billing Phone:

1-800-59UTICA
Available 24/7

Billing Address:

Utica National Insurance Group
PO Box 6532
Utica, NY 13504-6532

Express Payments:

Utica National Insurance Group
Attn. Credit & Collections
180 Genesee Street
New Hartford, NY 13413
Details:

You will need the policy holder’s account number or policy number and zip code. To pay, you can use your Checking/Savings Account. Personal lines only will accept a Visa, Discover, or MasterCard Credit Card.

On the webpage, you must log into the Customer Care Center. Once signed up, you can:

  • Pay your bill
  • File a claim
  • Review your account information

There is no charge for payments made over the phone using the automated system. A $10 fee is applied to phone payments made with a customer service representative.

Save time each month and never forget to pay your bill by signing up for recurring EFT payments. Download the enrollment form or contact us for more information.